How do wars affect real estate prices in Israel? What does history teach?
How do wars affect real estate prices in Israel? What does history teach?
When war breaks out in Israel, One of the first questions that arises for property owners, Buyers and investors is:
What will happen to apartment prices?
Have prices gone down?
Will the buyers stop the purchases?
Will directly affected areas lose value?
Or after the situation stabilizes, Will the market return to activity?
Those who try to find one answer in the history of Israel, will be difficult.
The previous wars teach something else:
The real estate market does not only react to the war itself.
It is also affected by the interest rate, from inflation, from the offer of apartments, from the demand, from the employment situation, from the geographical area and the duration of the crisis.
Therefore, the same war can have a different effect on Tel Aviv, Haifa, Rishon LeZion or a settlement that is under direct threat.
War does not necessarily cause prices to fall
This is perhaps the most important conclusion.
It is impossible to say:
War = falling prices.
But it is also impossible to say:
War = rising prices.
History shows that both things can happen.
In the Second Lebanon War, for example, Apartment prices fell in 2007 in the national average by about 1.6%, But the decline was sharper in the areas that were directly affected: apartment prices in Haifa dropped by about 10.5% and apartment prices in the northern district by about 5.5%.
That is, The location and strength of the impact are very important.
The Yom Kippur War - an example of how the war is only part of the story
The period after the Yom Kippur War also proves that it is impossible to isolate the war from the rest of the economy.
Israel entered a period of very high inflation and significant changes in the construction industry.
According to data based on the Bank of Israel report, Apartment prices also rose in 1974, But in real terms - in relation to the consumer price index - the picture was different, At the same time, there was a decrease in private construction starts.
That is, You can't just look at the price of the apartment in shekels and conclude from it if the market has really strengthened.
And what happened after the Second Lebanon War?
Here too the picture is interesting.
in the year 2007, The year after the war, There was a moderate decrease in apartment prices at the national level.
But in the areas directly hit by the shootings the declines were greater.
later on, in 2008, There has been a moderation in the decline and even a recovery in some areas.
The conclusion:
The real estate market can first react with an injury and then recover.
Therefore, the point in time at which the market is measured matters a lot.
The second intifada is a completely different example
The years of the second intifada also show how dangerous it is to build an automatic rule.
In the early 2000s, apartment prices in Israel fell, when in 2003 There was a decrease of about 6% in the national average prices. The period was also accompanied by recession and economic weakness.
That is, It is impossible to say that the decrease was caused only by the security incidents.
The security situation and the economic situation were connected to each other.
And that's exactly the point.
And what have we learned from the southern regions and surrounding Gaza?
Here, too, one should be very careful about sweeping conclusions.
A region that has been under security threat for years does not necessarily behave exactly like a region that has experienced a short war.
On the one hand, A persistent threat could hurt demand.
on the other hand, Real estate prices are also affected by the supply of land, from immigration, from employment, from infrastructure and the development of the region.
Therefore, it is not correct to take the long-term price increase in a certain city and conclude from it that wars do not affect prices.
There are historical examples where areas that received direct fire were significantly more affected than the national market.
And what happens during a war in terms of buyers?
One of the recurring phenomena is a slowdown in decision-making.
A buyer can continue looking for an apartment, But reject the signature.
why?
Because he doesn't know what will happen tomorrow.
Maybe the workplace will be damaged.
Maybe the interest rate will change.
Maybe family expenses will increase.
And maybe he just doesn't want to make a decision of millions of shekels in a time of uncertainty.
Therefore, in a difficult security period, there can be a gap between:
Who wants to buy
and between
Who is ready to buy now.
And what happens to the sellers?
There is no single answer here either.
There is a seller who can wait.
There is a seller who needs the money.
Some have already purchased another apartment.
There are those who fall into financial difficulty.
And there are those who simply decided it was time to sell.
Therefore, in wartime, a greater gap can arise between:
price the seller wants
and between
price a buyer is willing to pay.
Those who need to sell quickly may be more flexible than those who can wait.
MMD became a more significant consideration
One of the interesting changes measured during the Iron Swords War is the importance of MMD.
A study by the Bank of Israel found that at the beginning of the war, the premium that the price of the apartment with MMD received temporarily increased, And later the premium in transaction prices returned to the pre-war level and even decreased a little. in the rental market, However, A significant increase in the premium for the MMD was found.
This is a very important point:
War not only changes the amount of demand - it can also change what buyers are looking for.
Suddenly from M.D, receiver, floor, Accessibility and protected space receive greater weight in the decision.
Not every area reacts the same way
This is especially true in Israel.
An apartment in a city that is far from a combat zone can behave differently than an apartment that is under direct threat.
And even within the same city there can be differences.
one street.
one building.
One property type.
can be completely different from another property.
Therefore when considering the effect of the war on real estate, need to ask:
Where is the property?
What is the threat level?
Is there a MMD?
What is the condition of the building?
And what is the state of local demand?
And what about Rishon Lezion?
Rishon Lezion is an excellent example of the need to look at the market at the local level.
The city is very large and consists of different neighborhoods, Different construction types and different buyer groups.
during a security crisis, Not every property in Rishon Lezion will necessarily react in the same way.
New apartment with MMD, Parking and an elevator can have a different demand than an old apartment without an MMD.
A new neighborhood can behave differently from an old neighborhood.
And an apartment in one area of the city can behave differently than an apartment in another area.
That's why when a seller or buyer in Rishon Lezion asks me:
"What does the war do to prices?"
My answer is:
"Which property? Where? And when?"
Don't just look at the price of the apartment
There is more data to check.
The number of transactions
Marketing time
The number of competing properties
the level of demand
Actual transaction prices
mortgage interest
Buyers' financing ability
and employment status.
It may be that the price has hardly changed, But the number of transactions decreased significantly.
This means that the market is weakening - even if you don't see a sharp drop in prices yet.
The interest rate also plays a role
It is impossible to analyze a wartime real estate market without taking into account the financing.
Home buyers are largely dependent on mortgages.
when financing is more expensive, The purchasing power of some customers is affected.
Therefore even if the security situation improves, The housing market does not necessarily immediately return to normal.
The Bank of Israel noted in its reviews that the war was accompanied by economic uncertainty and affected the activity in the economy and the financial system.
And what happens after the war ends?
This is usually where an interesting phase begins.
Some of the buyers who were waiting are returning to the market.
Some of the sellers who have been waiting are returning properties to marketing.
Rejected transactions begin to commit.
And sometimes there is a wave of demand that has accumulated during the waiting period.
But there is no formula here either.
Recovery can be quick.
and can be slow.
Everything also depends on the state of the economy after the war.
Why can't we just rely on history?
Because every war is different.
The Six Day War was different from the Yom Kippur War.
The Second Lebanon War was different from the Second Intifada.
And iron swords are different from all of them.
different for.
different in intensity.
different in the scope of the damage.
And different in the impact on daily life.
Therefore, history can provide points of comparison, But it is not a prediction.
So is it worth buying during wartime?
It is a decision that depends on the person and the property.
Those who have financial ability, A long horizon and a property that suits him can find an interesting deal even in a complex period.
on the other hand, Those whose financial capacity is unstable or whose transaction depends on marginal financing should be more careful.
Don't buy just because:
"Prices will surely go down."
And don't buy just because:
"After every war, prices go up."
Both statements are too simplistic.
And what about a seller?
The seller should also ask:
Do I have to sell now?
What is the real value of the property?
How many properties are competing with me?
How long can I wait?
What does selling at a lower price mean?
And do I have an alternative?
Sometimes a slightly lower price today is better than waiting a year.
And sometimes it's better to wait.
It's an economic decision, No password.
What have we learned from previous wars?
If history has to be summed up in a few sentences:
War can hurt the market in the short term.
Areas that are directly affected can be more affected.
supply, Demand and interest are just as important as the security situation.
Prices do not always respond immediately.
And not every war ends with the same result.
This is perhaps less dramatic than the headline "After a war, prices always rise", But it is much closer to reality.
Real estate survey - looking at the property, Not on the title
As someone who works in the real estate market in Rishon Lezion, I don't like answering a question like:
"What will happen to apartment prices after the war?"
without asking first:
which apartment
In which neighborhood?
On which street?
how is she doing
what is the price
What is the level of demand?
And what is the financial situation of the buyer or seller?
Because in the end there is no "one real estate market".
There are many small markets within the big market.
The bottom line
The history of the real estate market in Israel shows that wars affect the market - but there is no automatic rule according to which prices always rise or always fall.
In the Second Lebanon War, for example, Areas directly affected recorded sharper declines than the national market.
in other periods, Recovery was faster, and at the same time factors such as inflation, Interest, Construction and supply greatly influenced the outcome.
Therefore, those who buy or sell an apartment in a complex security period should look less at general forecasts and more at the specific property, the neighborhood, employment and economic capacity.
And especially on Rishon LeZion, It is important to get down to the neighborhood and street level.
כי בסופו של דבר:
המלחמה משפיעה על השוק.
אבל העסקה שלכם מושפעת מהנכס שלכם.
Hash real estate - sale • rental • property management
קונים או מוכרים דירה בראשון לציון בתקופה של אי־ודאות?
בחיש נדל״ן אנחנו מכירים את השוק המקומי ומסייעים לבעלי נכסים ולקונים לבחון את העסקה בהתאם לנכס, למיקום, למחירי העסקאות ולמצב השוק.
053-3544055 | www.hish-nadlan.com
Real estate sense - more value, More results
המידע במאמר הוא מידע כללי ואינו מהווה תחזית למחירי הדירות או ייעוץ השקעות, taxation, משכנתאות או משפטי. מחירי הנדל״ן מושפעים מגורמים רבים ומשתנים לאורך זמן.