But will the real estate market face a war situation?
The existing legal situation in the case of damage to real estate projects and urban renewal following war,
And detailed the concepts that everyone should know - from property tax to insurance and sales law
It seems that all the factors in the global economy were affected by the upheavals the world went through in the last two years, The war in Ukraine which increased the prices of transporting goods but not only and contributed to the increase in prices in the housing market.
these events, And especially the sights of the bombed cities in Ukraine, Among the actors operating in the field of urban renewal and real estate in Israel - entrepreneurs, Garden / triplex apartment, Financing and insurance bodies alike - a particularly repressed threat scenario and a question on its side: what will happen to projects that will be physically damaged to a serious extent in the event of a security incident - for example during a missile attack on city centers? Who will be responsible for bearing the costs associated with the loss of the investment in it, And in general?
now, When in Israel there is already talk of war and even a possible attack by Hezbollah in the north, It is not unreasonable to return to the question of what will happen in a war situation. In order to create certainty in the field for any scenario in advance, We looked at what it means and what the legal solution is for receiving compensation in this case.
Answers should be divided into three parts, According to the three main stages in the life of a construction project: 1. pre permit 2. Building permit and receiving bank support 3. Delivery of the apartments. The most complex stage in the scenario of a severe damage to the project is the second stage, Therefore, in the framework of the present article, we will focus on this.
In the remaining phase and bank financing
When conducting a risk analysis for a project in a state of war, including physical harm to him, This stage has the most ramified and varied consequences - on the delivery of the apartments, on the execution schedules, on the credit frameworks and policies approved at the beginning of the project according to the zero report, and more.
From the point of view of the financing body, The chain of cases here leads, among other things, to a reexamination of the project and its economic viability. The increase in the credit frameworks also includes all the extensions caused by the war, including the extension of offshore guarantees, rental guarantees, interest for the various credits and the like. incidentally, The experience of the recent past (for example, the spread of the corona virus) shows that the state is in no hurry to define extreme situations as "force majeure" and to compensate the players in the economy for them.
Because of this we must understand, Because the issue is critical to the examination of the agreements signed today and the examination of the insurance policies, From the beginning until the delivery of the apartment in a few years. therefore, The parties must review the clauses of all agreements at any point in time, And at the same time learn from past rulings and state decisions in previous wars and try to take into account every possible scenario.
As of the writing of this article, When we check the known and accepted insurance policies in Israel, These do not respond as required during war in the case of property tax and we do not refer to exceptional and special policies that include war situations. Not this one either, In the insurance policies there is a specific clause that states for example: "The policy will not cover any damage for which the insured and/or a third party has the right to compensation according to the property tax law and the compensation fund".
Even if we examine the law of sale (apartments), it seems that there is no concrete reference to wartime. Although there is a reference to the delay in the delivery of the apartments, But not in a way that provides a clear and unequivocal answer on the subject, especially since we already know how the state has treated situations of this type in the past, including in the well-known Tzodler case in the Gulf War. As a side note, we note that during this period, (1900-1991) apartment prices soared over 30%, a very important point that can itself help with possible solutions and a very limited exposure of the financing bodies.
The horror scenario
Of course due to a total war, The exposure to the fall of the projects can be in several centers at the same time, Which will put the financing body and even the state into insolvency. in this case, Entrepreneurs will have no choice but to provide additional equity capital, Beyond what has already been invested in the project, And this is to try and increase its value. Yet, In this situation, it does not seem that the entrepreneur will be able to meet his obligations, Because all his assets will be damaged and so will their values. Such a situation will almost certainly lead to a "default" of all the parties involved, especially in a situation where there will be a drop in prices in the market. for that matter, It is important to note as a positive point of light, that an examination of the subject during the period when there was a war in Israel, In most periods there was an increase in the value of real estate (apartments and land). In the aforementioned inspection, we did not refer to the period in which inflation reached three-digit rates, and therefore, as aforesaid, We will not refer to the apartment prices during this period for the purpose of comparison.
A number of judgments - the most prominent of which is A.A 715/78, Aryeh Katz v. Nadhoni Mizrahi Ltd, PDI Leg (3) 639 - It has already been established that in the State of Israel it is possible and even requested to assume the possibility of the existence of war. But as of today, There is great difficulty in accepting a contractor's claim, for example, Against thwarting a contract due to the security situation. this, Because Israel is a country where "the unexpected is always within the scope of the expected for a person from Israel", As Judge Landoy said in the above judgment.
Judge Landoy stated in that appeal that as long as peace is not maintained between Israel and all its neighbors, The danger of war is always present, and therefore not impossible, Because this foreseeable danger negates the claim of deterrence due to the outbreak of war.
which therefore, And as a lesson from the Corona crisis, The legislator should give his opinion to a state of war, and settle the issue clearly, while providing a specific response to projects that may be damaged, God forbid, among others within the framework of a special compensation fund such as property tax and compensation fund
A small compensation and an optimistic conclusion
Until the aforementioned regulation, Property Tax and Compensation Fund Law 2015 1961 Including the relevant regulations, compensation for war damages of three types is provided, The most relevant of which are: war damage - damage caused to the body of an asset due to war operations by the regular armies of the enemy or due to other hostile actions against Israel or due to war operations by the IDF; and indirect damage - loss or prevention of profit as a result of war damage in settlements defined by the Minister of Finance as eligible.
In light of the aforementioned, The option available today is a claim for compensation from property tax and the compensation fund. Additionally, Claims can always be filed for direct damage caused to assets due to combat or hostilities, according to the law.
in over 75 years of existence, The State of Israel did not deal with the above issue. This is the opportunity to remind that it is never too late to take care of it, To wish us all a prosperous real estate market, That is not required for this issue and that we will not know wars, Like now war operation iron swords